Sheep Dog vs Skrewball: Peanut Butter Whiskey Compared NZ

Sheep Dog vs Skrewball: Peanut Butter Whiskey Compared NZ

November 14, 2026Weston W

Peanut butter whiskey has become one of the most popular party drinks in New Zealand. Two brands lead the way: Sheep Dog and Skrewball. Both are smooth, sweet and nutty, but they are not the same. Here is how they compare on taste, price and value, and why the 1L bottles are the smartest buy.

Quick Answer: Which Should I Buy?

Sheep Dog vs Skrewball at a Glance

Sheep Dog Skrewball
Style Sweet and creamy Rich, roasted and salty-sweet
Peanut flavour Soft, peanut butter cookie Bold, freshly roasted peanuts
Sweetness Sweeter Balanced with a salty edge
Best for Shots, mixing, big parties Sipping on ice, cocktails
1L price $64.99 $74.99
1L price per 100ml $6.50 $7.50

Prices are in NZD at the time of writing. Check the product page for the current price.

Why the 1L Bottle Is the Best Buy

If you enjoy peanut butter whiskey, the 1L bottle is the clear winner on value. You get 300ml more than a standard 700ml bottle for only a little more money:

  • Sheep Dog 1L works out at about $6.50 per 100ml, compared with about $8.00 per 100ml for the 200ml bottle.
  • Skrewball 1L works out at about $7.50 per 100ml, compared with about $7.86 for the 700ml and $9.50 for the 200ml.
  • A 1L bottle pours around 33 shots of 30ml, enough for a party, a barbecue or a long summer.

Peanut butter whiskey is rarely a one-shot drink. Once the bottle is open at a party, it goes fast, so the bigger bottle saves you money and a second trip to the shop.

Sheep Dog Peanut Butter Whiskey 1L Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey 1L

Sheep Dog Peanut Butter Whiskey

Sheep Dog is sweet, smooth and creamy, with a soft peanut butter cookie flavour, vanilla and caramel. It is very easy to drink, which makes it a favourite for ice-cold shots and simple mixed drinks. If you are buying for a crowd or you like your drinks on the sweeter side, Sheep Dog is the one.

Shop the full Sheep Dog range, or go straight to the best value Sheep Dog 1L.

Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey

Skrewball is an American peanut butter whiskey known for its bold, roasted peanut flavour and a salty-sweet finish that keeps it from tasting too sugary. It has a richer, fuller body, so it works well on the rocks as well as in cocktails. If you want the most peanut flavour in your glass, choose Skrewball.

Shop the full Skrewball range, including the Skrewball Sack of 5 x 50ml for parties, or go straight to the best value Skrewball 1L.

How to Drink Peanut Butter Whiskey

  • Ice-cold shot: keep the bottle in the freezer and serve straight.
  • On the rocks: pour over a large ice cube and sip slowly. Skrewball shines here.
  • With cola: 45ml peanut butter whiskey topped with cola and ice.
  • With milk: 45ml with cold milk over ice for an adult peanut butter milkshake.

Three Easy Peanut Butter Whiskey Cocktails

PB and J Shot: equal parts peanut butter whiskey and a raspberry liqueur such as Chambord, shaken with ice and strained into a shot glass.

Peanut Butter Espresso Martini: 30ml peanut butter whiskey, 30ml vodka, 30ml coffee liqueur such as Kahlua and a fresh espresso, shaken hard with ice and strained into a chilled glass.

Peanut Butter Cup: 30ml peanut butter whiskey and 30ml Baileys with a splash of chocolate syrup, shaken with ice and served over fresh ice.

FAQs

Is Sheep Dog or Skrewball better?

It depends on your taste. Sheep Dog is sweeter and creamier and is the better value, while Skrewball has a bolder roasted peanut flavour with a salty-sweet finish.

Which peanut butter whiskey is best value in NZ?

The Sheep Dog 1L is the best value at about $6.50 per 100ml. For Skrewball, the 1L is also the best value at about $7.50 per 100ml.

Is peanut butter whiskey real whiskey?

Both Sheep Dog and Skrewball are flavoured whiskeys, made with whiskey and peanut butter flavour.

Can people with nut allergies drink peanut butter whiskey?

Both contain peanut flavour. Anyone with a nut allergy should check the label and avoid them if unsure.

Do you deliver peanut butter whiskey across New Zealand?

Yes, we deliver throughout New Zealand. Delivery is included on orders over $250. You must be 18 or over to purchase alcohol. See our shipping and refund policy for details.

Please drink responsibly. You must be 18 or over to purchase alcohol in New Zealand.

More articles